X

I Play Rocky Review: Anthony Ippolito Shines in Sylvester Stallone Biopic

Kiki Seto as Talia Shire and Anthony Ippolito as Sylvester Stallone in ‘I PLAY ROCKY’ (Photo © 2026 Amazon Content Services LLC)

A low-budget film written by and starring a virtually unknown actor named Sylvester Stallone premiered in November 1976 in New York City. The film – Rocky – about a down-and-out boxer, went on to be a huge success at the box office and received 10 Oscar nominations, winning three, including Best Picture. 50 years later, the behind-the-scenes story of how that classic underdog film came to be is the focus of I Play Rocky.

I Play Rocky opens in New York in 1974 with a young Sylvester Stallone (Anthony Ippolito, The Offer) working a series of dead-end jobs while he auditions for bit parts, like thug number two or cop number four. Acting doesn’t pay the bills, so he takes a job as a ticket taker at a small movie theater. Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb, Grosse Pointe Garden Society), a pretty blonde co-worker, immediately catches his eye, and he falls hard, even though they’ve just met. During their courtship, Sasha notices that her struggling actor boyfriend has a wealth of knowledge about movie-making. Sylvester admits his frustration of never being offered any decent roles, and she encourages him to write his own script, advising him to give himself the best part.

Their struggles to stay afloat continue as the film jumps ahead 16 months, with Sasha and Sylvester now living together in Los Angeles. While parking cars as a restaurant valet, a regular diner, who’s in the movie business, hooks Sylvester up with an interview with two producers: Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) and Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne). After an unsuccessful meeting, Sylvester slips his own script for the film Paradise Alley into a pile of scripts to be read. The script is brought to Chartoff and Winkler’s attention, and they actually encourage Sylvester to bring them any other of his scripts, recognizing he has talent.

A few weeks later at a bar, Sylvester watches the Muhammad Ali-Chuck Wepner fight and becomes inspired to write a boxing movie. He hammers out the script for Rocky in just three and a half days. Chartoff and Winkler love it and immediately start throwing around names of actors to play the lead, suggesting Clint Eastwood, Charles Bronson, and even Ryan O’Neal. However, Sylvester quickly shuts them down, saying, “Guys, I play Rocky.” Chartoff and Winkler assure Sylvester that won’t happen, but Sylvester is adamant. He wrote the film to play the part. He is Rocky.

Eager to make the film, Chartoff and Winkler try negotiating with studio head Sandy Maddox (Tracy Letts), who refuses to give an unknown the lead. He likes the script and orders them to throw money at Sylvester to buy it from him. They do, but of course no matter how generous the offer, Sylvester stands firm. “I’m not giving this up. Not for a million bucks, not for ten,” says Sly. Eager to make the film and genuinely respecting Sylvester’s determination, Chartoff and Winkler use the legal loophole that they can cast anyone they want if they make the film for under $1 million. Now the pressure is on to stay on schedule, stay on budget, and keep Sylvester from getting injured; otherwise, the studio can replace him as the lead.

Inspiring and entertaining, I Play Rocky is a crowd-pleasing, emotionally stirring biopic loaded with outstanding performances. Anthony Ippolito delivers a knock-out performance as Slyvester Stallone. Ippolito disappears into the role so convincingly that audiences may forget it’s not Stallone on screen. He’s just that phenomenal!

AnnaSophia Robb shines as Sasha, Stallone’s first wife who encouraged him with his career, typed up his movie scripts, and was behind the scenes helping make Rocky work. Robb has wonderful chemistry with Ippolito and really embodies Sasha’s tough, scrappy nature and no-nonsense attitude.

Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne are perfectly cast as Stallone’s producers, Chartoff and Winkler, who believe in him and his boxing movie and do everything they can – and then some – to make the film while dealing with overwhelming obstacles. Kebbell and Byrne are scene-stealers.

I Play Rocky brings back to life the look, feel, and sounds of the 1970s, both in New York and Los Angeles, via costumes, cars, sets, and hairstyles. It also captures the spirit of what made Rocky such an underdog success. Fans of Sylvester Stallone or the Rocky franchise, as well as those interested in the behind-the-scenes deal-making and drama around making independent films, will absolutely enjoy stepping into the ring with I Play Rocky. It’s a fascinating look at the origin of a cinema classic.

GRADE: B+

Release Date: November 20, 2026
Runtime: 2 hours 8 minutes
Rating: PG-13 for brief sexual material, strong language, and smoking
Directed by: Peter Farrelly
Studio: Amazon MGM Studios

 

This post was last modified on November 18, 2026 12:10 pm

Kevin Finnerty: Professional film critic since 2003 and a member of the San Diego Film Critics Society. Host of “The Movie Guys” radio film review show from 2007 through 2013. Film and television critic for Showbizjunkies.com and a movie buff since 1973.
Related Post